Keyboard Builders' Digest / Tips & Tricks
Tactile stems
Tactile stem comparison by jk_pens.
Published June 27, 2021
Creators! Feel free to tip me off about your keyboard related projects to bring them to 140K readers.
Opening up a bunch of tactile switches to make some frankenswitches, jk_pens used digital calipers to measure the stems.
Specifically, I measured the difference between the deepest "trough" in the tactile leg and the "peak". This represents the maximum distance the tactile leaf spring is depressed when the key is pressed.
A picture to help understand what is being measured: https://imgur.com/gallery/tn8nBUY
Perhaps unsurprisingly, both Cherry MX and Gateron browns came out at the bottom of the ranking by this measure.
On top of that, some experiments I did with swapping in more tactile stems confirm that the brown switches also have relatively weak tactile leaf springs. For example, a Polia stem in a Gateron brown is more tactile than the stock brown, but not as tactile as the same stem in a U4T housing.
Note that the differences in tactile leaf springs and other factors such as the shape of the tactile leg mean that this ranking by itself may not give you an accurate assessment of the overall tactility of any of these switches.
Published on Sun 27th Jun 2021. Featured in KBD #32 (source).
Related
Ultra low profile switch by Cherry
Cherry announces a new ultra low profile SMD switch (details). Posted by stuartsoft.
MX compatible maglev switch
3D printable magnetic levitation switch with the Hall effect sensor in a Cherry MX compatible housing.
TTC Wild switch review
TTC Wild linear switches reviewed by ThereminGoat.
Taiwan Jet Axis switch review
ThereminGoat ventures on vintage territory with reviewing Taiwan Jet Axis switches.
KK Light Wave V2 / Candy Jade Green
Deadeye is starting a video series where he takes an in-depth look at various mechanical switches, the fist one being KK Light Wave V2.