Save 5% at Lume Keebs! Code: KBDNEWS
The BSUN x Punkshoo Melody Redux and Gateron Banana Smoothie switches are both standard MX mechanical switches of the tactile breed. They both feature POM top housing, POM bottom housing, POM stem material, standard stem shape, - g , - mm , 3.40 mm total travel, however, they come with different spring (60g vs dual-stage), bottom-out force (60 g vs 65 g). That said, they are nearly identical. Let's check out this side-by-side specs rundawn with details, availability -- and even current prices -- to figure out which one fits you the best!
The BSUN x Punkshoo Melody Redux is a tactile standard MX mechanical switch with POM top housing, POM bottom housing, and POM stem (standard shape). It features a 60g spring. The 60g bottom-out occurs at 3.40mm. Factory lubing? Yes! Designed by Punkshoo. Manufactured by BSUN. | The Gateron Banana Smoothie is a tactile standard MX mechanical switch with POM top housing, POM bottom housing, and POM stem (standard shape). It features a dual-stage spring. The 60g actuation occurs at 2mm. The 65g bottom-out occurs at 3.40mm. Extra: Light diffuser. Factory lubing? Yes! Manufactured by Gateron. |
|
|
| Name | BSUN x Punkshoo Melody Redux | Gateron Banana Smoothie |
|---|---|---|
| Type | tactile | tactile |
| Footprint | 5-pin | 5-pin |
| Top housing | POM | POM |
| Bottom housing | POM | POM |
| Stem material | POM | POM |
| Stem shape | standard | standard |
| Spring | 60g | dual-stage |
| Tactile force | - g | - g |
| Actuation | - g | 60 g |
| Bottom-out | 60 g | 65 g |
| Tactile bump position | - mm | - mm |
| Pre-travel | - mm | 2 mm |
| Total travel | 3.40 mm | 3.40 mm |
| Lube | Factory lubing? Yes! | Factory lubing? Yes! |
| Designer | Punkshoo | - |
| Manufacturer | BSUN | Gateron |
By tracking prices and in-stock status of 30+ well-known keyboard stores worldwide, we can state that the BSUN x Punkshoo Melody Redux is available at a single shop at the moment, while the Gateron Banana Smoothie can be found in multiple stores.
Clicking the links below take you to some notable keyboard shops offering BSUN x Punkshoo Melody Redux and Gateron Banana Smoothie switches. When accepted, the prices indicated already include the discount - use the KBDNEWS coupon code at checkout to claim your saving!
Prices, discounts, and stock status are checked regularly; however, changes since the last update cannot be ruled out. Everything here is for informational purposes only. Check the product pages for the latest prices!
Comments on BSUN x Punkshoo Melody Redux switches | Comments on Gateron Banana Smoothie switches |
The goal of this redesign was to emulate as much of the OG Melody principles as possible while also adopting a slightly new look, sound and feel by embracing the parameters of the new manufacturer’s tooling. Ultimately, we landed on a slightly desaturated and shifted colorway that differentiates itself but also captures the same vibe of the original. Additionally, POM was chosen as a material all around because it delivers the interesting full yet muted sound profile, albeit a slightly higher pitched. This also allows Melody Redux to stand out more in a sea of traditional materials used across the gamut of recolors. Lastly, the parameters of BSUNs molds allowed for the creation of a new, fun feel. We retain some of that “linearn’t” feel but add a bit of shimmy on the press with a nice snappy, tactile response on the return. While it is different than the original, it offers that same vibe that the Melody project has always sought to capture; fun – KeebzNCables. | Gateron Banana Smoothie switches are heavy tactile mechanical switches that deliver a sharper, more pronounced tactile bump than standard brown switches, ideal for users who like strong, deliberate feedback with each keystroke. As the heavy tactile member of Gateron’s full-POM Smoothie lineup, Banana Smoothie combines a dual-stage spring with full POM housing and stem for a smooth yet firm keypress and excellent durability. A detachable light guide window ensures clean, bright RGB or backlighting while maintaining compatibility with modern SMD LED backlit mechanical keyboards – mechboards. |
