While the WingTree Camellia and HMX Lulu Silent switches may have some significant differences, they are at least compatible: both are standard MX mechanical switches. That said, the WingTree Camellia is linear, while the HMX Lulu Silent is of linear type. They both feature PA66 Nylon bottom housing, standard stem shape, 52 g bottom-out force, 2 mm pre-travel, however, they come with different top housing (PA66 Nylon vs PC), stem material (modified POM vs POM), spring (19 mm for 48g and 58g bottom out, 20 mm for 52g bottom out vs 22 mm single-stage), actuation (42 g vs 45 g), total travel (4 mm vs 3.80 mm). All in all: they are only slightly similar. Let's check out this side-by-side specs rundawn with more details, availability -- and even current prices -- to figure out which one fits you the best!
The WingTree Camellia is a linear standard MX mechanical switch with PA66 Nylon top housing, PA66 Nylon bottom housing, and modified POM stem (standard shape). It features a 19 mm for 48g and 58g bottom out, 20 mm for 52g bottom out spring. The 42g actuation occurs at 2mm. The 52g bottom-out occurs at 4mm. Factory lubing? Yes! Designed by Wuhai Studio. Manufactured by WingTree. | The HMX Lulu Silent is a linear standard MX mechanical switch with PC top housing, PA66 Nylon bottom housing, and POM stem (standard shape). It features a 22 mm single-stage spring. The 45g actuation occurs at 2mm. The 52g bottom-out occurs at 3.80mm. Extra: Light diffuser. Factory lubing? Yes! Manufactured by HMX. |
|
|
| Name | WingTree Camellia | HMX Lulu Silent |
|---|---|---|
| Type | linear | linear |
| Footprint | 5-pin | 5-pin |
| Top housing | PA66 Nylon | PC |
| Bottom housing | PA66 Nylon | PA66 Nylon |
| Stem material | modified POM | POM |
| Stem shape | standard | standard |
| Spring | 19 mm for 48g and 58g bottom out, 20 mm for 52g bottom out | 22 mm single-stage |
| Actuation | 42 g | 45 g |
| Bottom-out | 52 g | 52 g |
| Pre-travel | 2 mm | 2 mm |
| Total travel | 4 mm | 3.80 mm |
| Lube | Factory lubing? Yes! Stem legs and stem sliders are covered with a very thin coat of 205g0. The spring and leaf are lubed with dry film. Everything else is dry. There is no lube in the bottom housing or anywhere near the stem pole. The chance that these get lube pooling issue is very small. | Factory lubing? Yes! |
| Designer | Wuhai Studio | - |
| Manufacturer | WingTree | HMX |
By tracking prices and in-stock status of 30+ well-known keyboard stores worldwide, we can state that the HMX Lulu Silent is available at a single shop at the moment, while the WingTree Camellia can be found in multiple stores.
Clicking the links below take you to some notable keyboard shops offering WingTree Camellia and HMX Lulu Silent switches. When accepted, the prices indicated already include the discount - use the KBDNEWS coupon code at checkout to claim your saving!
Prices, discounts, and stock status are checked regularly; however, changes since the last update cannot be ruled out. Everything here is for informational purposes only. Check the product pages for the latest prices!
WingTree Camellia sound test | HMX Lulu Silent sound test |
No HMX Lulu Silent sound test available. |
Comments on WingTree Camellia switches | Comments on HMX Lulu Silent switches |
The WingTree Camellia linear switch is a full-travel, long-pole linear switch designed by Wuhai Studio and manufactured by Wingtree. The Camellia switch features an all-new mold that's developed based on the previous mold Wingtree Yuying Black switches used. After the mold design modifications, Camellia now sounds cleaner, less noisy, and more concentrated at the bottom out; The scratchy feel has also been improved, which is still grainy but much more refined. Each switch comes factory lubed, with a thin layer of Krytox 205g0 applied to the stem legs and sliders, while the spring and leaf are also lubricated to ensure a smooth, consistent feel right out of the box. FYI: If you are looking for maximum scratch, please choose the dry options which only comes with factory-lubed leaf and spring – Unikeys. | No comments on HMX Lulu Silent switches. |
